The Silchar Municipal Corporation’s drive to remove roadside vendors raises serious questions about the administration’s approach to urban development, social responsibility and the livelihood rights of economically vulnerable citizens. Clearing roads and footpaths is necessary, but eviction without providing alternative vending spaces or rehabilitation arrangements risks pushing hundreds of small traders and their families into economic uncertainty
KRC TIMES Barak Valley Bureau
The drive to clear roads and public spaces of street vendors in Silchar has brought an important question to the forefront: should urban beautification and traffic management come at the cost of the livelihoods of some of the city’s most economically vulnerable residents? The Silchar Municipal Corporation has every reason to be concerned about the growing problem of roadside encroachment, traffic congestion and the obstruction of footpaths.
A town aspiring to develop into a modern urban centre must have properly organised roads, accessible pedestrian pathways, regulated markets and an efficient civic management system. However, the manner in which these objectives are pursued is equally important. Removing street vendors from roadsides without first making arrangements for their rehabilitation or providing alternative places to conduct business cannot be considered a comprehensive urban development policy.
It may temporarily make certain roads look wider and cleaner, but it does little to address the underlying problem. More importantly, it leaves those who depend on roadside vending for their daily survival facing an uncertain future. For a considerable number of small traders in Silchar, roadside vending is not a supplementary source of income or a temporary commercial activity. It is their principal means of livelihood.
Vegetable sellers, fruit vendors, tea stall owners, small food traders, garment sellers and numerous other petty businessmen depend on their daily earnings to maintain their families. Many operate with extremely limited capital and have no financial resources to establish shops in commercial buildings or rent expensive business premises. For these families, losing a vending space can mean losing their entire source of income overnight.
There is no denying that unregulated street vending can create difficulties for pedestrians, motorists and other residents. When vendors occupy substantial portions of footpaths or roads, public movement becomes difficult. Traffic congestion increases, and the overall appearance and functioning of the town suffer. But these problems cannot be addressed through eviction alone. A city administration must recognise that street vending is an integral part of the informal economy and that thousands of people across Indian towns and cities depend on it for survival.
The real challenge before the Silchar Municipal Corporation is to strike a balance between the legitimate interests of the general public and the livelihood rights of street vendors. Unfortunately, urban development initiatives often tend to concentrate more on visible changes than on the social consequences of administrative decisions. Clearing roadside stalls may produce an immediate impression of improvement, but unless the displaced vendors are provided with alternative spaces, the exercise risks becoming an act of displacement rather than meaningful reform.
The administration must understand that a clean and organised city cannot be built by simply removing economically weaker sections from public spaces. It requires planning, consultation, regulation and rehabilitation. The Street Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014, provides an important legal framework for regulat- ing street vending while protecting the livelihood interests of vendors.
The legislation recognises the contribution of street vendors to the urban economy and seeks to ensure that their activities are regulated through a systematic and transparent mechanism. It provides for surveys of street vendors, the constitution of Town Vending Committees, the issuance of certificates of vending and the identification of vending and non-vending zones. It also establishes safeguards relating to relocation and eviction.
The spirit of the legislation is clear: urban authorities must regulate street vending without unnecessarily destroying the livelihoods of those engaged in it. Therefore, the Silchar Municipal Corporation must ensure that any eviction or relocation exercise follows the applicable legal provisions. It should clarify whether a comprehensive survey of street vendors has been completed, whether the necessary institutional arrangements are in place and whether alternative vending locations have been identified.
The law does not suggest that street vendors should be allowed to occupy every available public space. Equally, it does not support the idea that they can simply be removed without following due process and considering their livelihood interests. This is perhaps the most important question that the Municipal Corporation needs to answer.

If roadside vendors are removed from their existing locations, where are they expected to conduct their businesses? Has the Corporation identified suitable alternative sites? Will the new locations be accessible to customers? Will the vendors be provided with basic facilities such as drinking water, sanitation, drainage and waste disposal?
A vending zone located far away from residential areas or commercial centres may technically provide space to traders, but it may not offer them a viable opportunity to earn a living. The success of rehabilitation cannot be measured merely by allocating an empty plot of land. The alternative location must have reasonable commercial viability and accessibility. The authorities must also consider the financial limitations of small traders.
They cannot be expected to pay high rental charges, licence fees or other expenses that make their businesses economically unviable. Rehabilitation must therefore be practical, affordable and designed around the actual needs of the affected vendors. One of the major shortcomings of top-down urban administration is the tendency to take decisions affecting ordinary citizens without adequately consulting those who will be directly impacted.
The street vendors of Silchar should not be treated merely as recipients of municipal orders. They must be recognised as stakeholders in the city’s development process. Before undertaking any major eviction or relocation exercise, the Municipal Corporation should hold consultations with representatives of street vendors, local market associations, residents’ groups and other relevant stakeholders.
Such consultations could help identify areas where vending creates genuine obstruction, locations where vending can be permitted under regulation and places suitable for developing organised vending markets. A transparent mechanism should also be established to address complaints and disputes relating to vending spaces. This would prevent arbitrary allocation, discrimination and unnecessary conflict between vendors and municipal authorities.
The administration should also consider issuing or updating vending certificates in accordance with the applicable legal framework so that eligible vendors have clarity about their rights and responsibilities. Instead of treating street vendors as a problem, the Silchar Municipal Corporation should consider developing organised vending markets in suitable locations across the town. Dedicated vending zones could be established in areas where commercial activity is possible without obstructing major roads or pedestrian movement.
These zones should have clearly demarcated stalls, adequate space for customers, proper drainage, drinking water, lighting, sanitation facilities and arrangements for regular waste collection. The Corporation could introduce a regulated system of operating hours in congested areas. In certain locations, vending could be permitted during designated hours, while sensitive stretches such as major intersections, emergency access routes and heavily used footpaths could be kept free from obstruction.
A transparent allotment system would ensure that vending spaces are distributed fairly among eligible traders. Such an arrangement would serve multiple purposes. It would reduce congestion, improve sanitation, protect pedestrian access and provide street vendors with a more secure business environment.
It would also help the Corporation bring an important segment of the informal economy into a more organised system of urban governance. The present controversy also raises a broader question about the nature of urban planning in Silchar. For years, the town has struggled with traffic congestion, inadequate parking, unregulated commercial activity, drainage problems, poor pedestrian infrastructure and increasing pressure on public spaces.
These problems cannot be attributed exclusively to street vendors. Unplanned commercial expansion, inadequate market infrastructure, insufficient parking facilities and weak enforcement of existing regulations have all contributed to the town’s urban management challenges. It would therefore be unfair to place the entire burden of these failures on small roadside traders. If the authorities are serious about making Silchar a better-managed city, they must adopt a comprehensive approach.
This should include the development of organised markets, improvement of public transport, creation of adequate parking facilities, protection of footpaths, scientific traffic management and strict enforcement of building and commercial regulations. Street vending must be addressed as one component of a larger urban planning strategy, not as an isolated problem to be solved through periodic eviction drives.
The most disturbing aspect of eviction without rehabilitation is its potential social impact. A small roadside business may generate only a modest daily income, but that income often supports an entire household. The sudden loss of business can affect children’s education, household expenses, healthcare and the ability to repay small loans. For people already struggling with rising prices and limited employment opportunities, such displacement can deepen financial insecurity.
The administration must also recognise that street vending provides affordable goods and services to a large section of the population. From daily vegetables and fruits to inexpensive meals and essential household items, these small businesses serve an important public purpose.
Their contribution to the urban economy should not be overlooked simply because they operate outside conventional commercial establishments.A humane administration does not ignore the difficulties faced by the general public, but neither does it overlook the economic consequences of its decisions on vulnerable communities.The Silchar Municipal Corporation now has an opportunity to demonstrate that urban development and social justice need not be contradictory objectives.
It should immediately undertake a comprehensive assessment of the affected vendors, identify suitable alternative locations and formulate a time-bound rehabilitation policy. The process should be transparent, legally compliant and based on consultations with the vendors themselves.
The Corporation should also make public its plans regarding vending zones, relocation arrangements and the criteria for allotment of alternative spaces. This would help prevent uncertainty and build public confidence. Where immediate action is necessary to remove serious obstructions, the authorities should follow due process and ensure that affected vendors are not left without a viable alternative.
The state government, too, should extend the necessary administrative and financial support to help the Municipal Corporation develop properly planned vending infrastructure. Ultimately, the objective should be to create a city where pedestrians can walk freely, vehicles can move without unnecessary obstruction, markets remain clean and organised, and small trad- ers can earn their livelihood with dignity.
Silchar deserves better roads, cleaner surroundings, improved infrastructure and efficient civic administration. But the measure of a city’s development is not simply how attractive its streets appear or how effectively roadside structures are removed. A truly developed city is one that provides opportunities to its people, protects vulnerable livelihoods and ensures that economic progress is inclusive. The street vendors of Silchar are not outsiders seeking to benefit from the city.
They are part of its everyday economic and social life. They serve its residents, contribute to local commerce and support families through honest, often difficult, labour. Their problems cannot be solved by making them disappear from the streets. The Silchar Municipal Corporation must therefore move beyond the narrow approach of eviction and adopt a policy that combines civic discipline with economic protection.
If roadside vending needs to be regulated, let it be regulated through proper planning. If vendors need to be relocated, let suitable alternative spaces be provided. And if the city needs to be beautified, let that process include the people whose livelihoods depend on its streets. Urban development must not become another name for economic displacement. Silchar needs cleaner roads, but it also needs protected livelihoods.
Eviction without rehabilitation is not development; it is merely the shifting of an urban problem from one place to another, while the poorest are made to pay the price. The real test of the Silchar Municipal Corporation will not be how many roadside vendors it can remove, but how successfully it can build an organised city without taking away the right of its ordinary citizens to earn a living with dignity.


