Industrial Growth Must Not Come at the Cost of Agricultural Land

5 - minutes read |

India’s vast population makes it imperative to maintain a balance between agriculture and industry

KRC TIMES Desk

 Durjati Mukherjee

Industrial development is undoubtedly essential, particularly for states that have lagged behind in this sector. However, NITI Aayog Vice-Chairman Ashok Lahiri’s recent observation that imposing a blanket ban on the acquisition of multi-crop agricultural land for industrial purposes would be inappropriate has raised several important questions. Speaking on the sidelines of the 19th Banking Colloquium organised by the eastern region of the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII), Lahiri argued that such restrictions could impede industrial growth and that each case should instead be assessed individually, with adequate compensation provided to landowners.

 While the need to promote industrialisation cannot be disputed, his argument appears to overlook the long-term consequences of converting fertile, multi-crop agricultural land into industrial zones.

Referring to West Bengal’s high population density, Lahiri acknowledged the importance of both agriculture and industry but appeared to favour industrial expansion. He argued that relatively low agricultural productivity justified giving greater priority to industry. He also suggested that setting up industries in hilly areas or near forests could be difficult because of inadequate infrastructure.

But why should infrastructure development necessarily come at the expense of agricultural land? Nor can monetary compensation alone be considered a practical solution. A large section of farmers, particularly those with limited education and alternative livelihood opportunities, may not possess the skills or resources required to build sustainable sources of income with the compensation they receive.

 Such an argument is difficult to justify in a predominantly rural country like India, where agriculture and allied activities remain major sources of livelihood. Rather than viewing agricultural land as an obstacle to industrialisation, policymakers should explore ways to increase farm productivity, diversify agricultural output and encourage high-value crops. Institutions such as the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR) and the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) could work together to develop innovative solutions. Lahiri should also consider urging NITI Aayog to take a more proactive approach towards strengthening the agricultural economy.

Know More https://bit.ly/KRCBrainVision Apply Here https://bit.ly/KRCBVForm
Promotional | For admission to the Brain Vision Program Know More | Apply Here

 The experience of Singur in West Bengal offers an important lesson. During the Left Front government’s tenure, multi-crop agricultural land was acquired for the Tata Motors factory, triggering a prolonged political and public movement. The controversy became one of the major factors behind the Trinamool Congress’s landslide victory in 2011. The present BJP government has expressed its intention to pursue a policy of purchasing land directly from landowners rather than resorting to compulsory acquisition for industrial projects. However, the more fundamental question remains: how will the long-term rehabilitation and livelihood security of displaced farmers be ensured? This must be treated as a priority.

 There is another aspect that deserves serious consideration. Despite increasing mechanisation over the years, the industrial sector has failed to generate sufficient employment opportunities for India’s expanding workforce. It is unclear whether this limitation has received adequate attention in the arguments favouring large-scale industrialisation. Instead, promoting agro-based industries, particularly those geared towards export markets, could generate substantial employment while strengthening rural economies.

 India’s vast population makes it imperative to maintain a balance between agriculture and industry. A significant proportion of the population continues to depend on farming for its livelihood. Improving farmers’ incomes must therefore remain a fundamental objective of economic policy. The challenges of a densely populated country, where millions live in rural and economically backward regions, cannot be addressed through the expansion of heavy industries alone.

 Experts have repeatedly raised concerns about the acquisition of agricultural land belonging to Adivasis, Dalits and fishing communities. In several instances, allegations of coercion, forced eviction, arrests and violations of legal safeguards have surfaced. Meanwhile, hills and forests are being cleared to make way for development projects, while villages are left vulnerable to submergence and displacement.

 Ironically, those living in relatively secure and unaffected areas often justify these developments as an unavoidable price of progress. People who oppose such projects are frequently branded as anti-national, while those supporting marginalised communities are sometimes accused of being criminals, religious conversion agents or foreign-sponsored elements.

Over the past century, many of these communities have systematically lost their land, cultural identity, languages and traditional ways of life. Their cultural contributions are often celebrated when the country seeks to showcase its diversity, but their economic and social rights receive far less attention. Poor and marginalised people are repeatedly promised employment and a better standard of living in the name of development. Yet, in many cases, they eventually find themselves reduced to wage labourers on land that once belonged to them, dependent on the goodwill of outside investors and employers.

 This is hardly an acceptable model of development. Is the primary objective of economic policy merely to increase per capita income among the top seven to eight per cent of the population while overlooking the condition of the bottom 25 to 30 per cent?

 Lahiri has also expressed views favouring large industries over micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs). His argument is that lending to a single large industrial unit is less expensive and administratively more convenient for banks than extending credit to numerous smaller enterprises. However, figures indicate that large companies accounted for an additional industrial credit expansion of Rs 2 lakh crore, while the MSME sector received Rs 1.6 lakh crore. These numbers underline the importance of ensuring that smaller enterprises, cottage industries and startups receive adequate institutional support.

 Startups deserve particular attention because of their technological capabilities and potential to expand rapidly in global markets. Encouraging these enterprises could also create new opportunities in technology-driven employment, allowing talented engineers and skilled professionals to put their expertise to productive use. Smaller enterprises and startups are often fertile grounds for innovation, and the government can play a crucial role by providing the necessary support for research and development (R&D).

Another important question concerns the rationale behind the incentives and concessions extended to large corporate houses. Their primary objective, after all, is profit maximisation. Many large companies generate relatively limited direct employment because of their capital-intensive operations and do not always demonstrate a strong commitment to the welfare of communities living around their project sites. In such circumstances, the justification for providing extensive public support to big corporations deserves closer scrutiny. Otherwise, economic policy risks reinforcing a model that disproportionately benefits corporate capital.

 The challenge before India is not simply to accelerate economic growth but to ensure that development is genuinely inclusive. Backward and marginalised communities must be integrated into economic activity, with particular attention paid to those at the bottom of the social and economic ladder. Growth that excludes them cannot be considered sustainable or equitable.

 Economist Ashok Lahiri may not agree with this approach, but an observation made by Mahatma Gandhi in the mid-1950s remains relevant to the debate. Gandhi envisaged the development of electricity, iron and steel, shipbuilding, machinery and other major industries. However, he argued that the priorities of industrialisation needed to be reversed. Instead of destroying villages and traditional handicrafts, industries should serve rural communities and strengthen their economic foundations.

 Gandhi’s vision may not be entirely applicable to the complexities of the modern economy. But that does not mean fertile agricultural land should simply be handed over to corporate houses in the name of industrial progress. India must explore a more balanced development model that protects agricultural livelihoods while creating opportunities for industrial expansion.

 Rather than concentrating incentives and concessions in the hands of large corporations, the government should encourage young entrepreneurs with innovative ideas and help them establish and expand their startups. Industrial growth is necessary, but it must not become a justification for undermining the livelihoods, land rights and economic security of those who have the least power to defend them.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

×

Hello!

Click one of our contacts below to chat on WhatsApp

× How can I help you?